With resin it does work and they pop really loud. Mine are made with 0-63 micron mgal.Have you heard that phenolic resin works, or have you experienced it? I'm just wondering as there are a lot of myths floating around in pyro. You can use dextrin too by the way. By lack of NC, I meant more a lack of confinement or consolidation, not that a certain amount is required for the effect. It seems that if the grains are too porus, the effect tends to suffer.
Maybe with rubbish crackling it can be too small, but normally a 1mm core pops quite loud already. The smouldering phase is really short, it just requires a little bit of hot prime.